How the Senate Exploits Unpaid InternsPosted: August 30, 2013
Barely a third of U.S. senators pay their interns — and embarrassingly for Democrats, a party focused on workplace welfare, most of them are Republicans.
By Stephen Lurie
If you walk into any of the 100 Senate offices spread across Capitol Hill, there is one consistent element. Marco Rubio’s furniture won’t be the same as Elizabeth Warren’s and Mark Udall’s landscape photographs won’t match Lindsey Graham’s wall hangings. The ubiquitous fixture of every Senate (and House) office is livelier: the young, sometimes bright-eyed, cohorts of interns that flood the Capitol in the summer.
Across the spectrum of industries, internships have been commonplace for decades, but the unpaid variety has come under close scrutiny only recently, following a number of high-profile incidents challenging the legitimacy of the practice — long bemoaned by many interns themselves. In June, a federal judge ruled for the first time that Fox Searchlight broke employment laws by not paying interns. Two days later, former interns at Condé Nast, who had been paid at a rate less than $1 an hour, filed suit against the magazine group. Condé Nast has recently revealed it has stopped paying interns altogether. Seeking a more conciliatory approach, interns at The Nation wrote a letter to their editors at the end of July instead of taking legal action, and were later rewarded by a promise of minimum wage. As the case of the unpaid intern garnered national attention, it wouldn’t be long before the national legislature would get its turn. That happened when Jessica Padron, who’s been offered an internship in the office of Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, took to Indiegogo to crowdfund her otherwise-unpaid internship.
These cases highlight the two major complaints about unpaid internships: First, that equal work deserves equal pay; and second, that unpaid internships exclude those of lower economic status. Reid won’t face the same legal consequences as Fox because Congress exempts itself from normal intern rules under the Congressional Accountability Act, but the story certainly ought to feed public ire over unpaid work on the Hill. Elected leaders’ positions on the issue are important. If there is going to be some sort of legislative change on what some liken to indentured servitude, it’s going to come from Congress.
To see where senators stand, one need look no further than how they operate their own internship programs. The answers, including who pays and who doesn’t, are a little surprising — and for Democratic defenders of labor fairness, as well as spending-slashing Republicans, they send a warning.
Just seeing where senators keep the information on their internships is telling. While some list internship info under a “Student” tab, most put it in “Service” or “Constituent Service” sections. Bizarrely lumped in with items like flag requests, resources for homeowners, federal resources, and the obligatory “Coffee with Senator X,” internship opportunities are construed as a favor your elected official is doing for you. For example, you can find information on how to intern for Joe Manchin, a West Virginia Democrat under the category of “Help From Joe.”
The argument that Senate offices, and employees nationwide for that matter, make is that the internship is exclusively for the benefit of the intern through educational experience. New Mexico Democrat Martin Heinrich’s website summarizes the sentiments of many offices when it states that “internships are available expressly for the purpose of furthering educational objectives.” Others, like Illinois Republican Mark Kirk, are blunter, noting that the internship “provides invaluable resume-building experience.” No matter how it’s phrased, these senators echo the private-sector mantra that interns are gaining instead of giving during their employ. Even though each senator details the litany of services interns are expected to perform, it is somehow understood that a full-time internship is a gift to the student, not the other way around.
But with a full workload — stacks of mail to open, constituent calls to answer, legislative research to do, and Capitol tours to give — internships on the Hill offer students the opportunity to give … and give and give. For those around these offices, it seems clear that Senate offices could not operate as they do without their cohort of intern laborers. They constantly supplement and replace work that would be done by staff or legislative assistants — or by no one at all.
A May column in Roll Call perhaps best exemplifies the use of interns. Titled “Maximizing Intern Contributions In Your Hill Office” the article is a primer on how to milk the most out of your free labor, particularly in today’s economy. As the author explains, “as a result of the budget cuts to congressional offices … professional interns who contribute to the office’s productivity is not only desirable for congressional offices, it is now an absolute need.” Despite thinly veiled suggestions that congressional internships are purely educational, this sort of strategizing seems to point to another use.
If internships on the Hill might not be purely educational, then, the natural follow-up is to determine how, if at all, interns are being compensated for their service — and which leaders are rewarding their public servants. The facts: only 35 senators compensate their interns. In most offices, summer interns are expected to gratefully work full-time in exchange for whatever exposure to national politics, and politicians, they might earn.
In an age of recession and sequestration, hiding behind budget restrictions is one easy excuse. Republican Richard Shelby of Alabama writes on his website, “Although I am unable to pay interns due to Senate budget restrictions, I believe that serving as a Congressional intern can prove to be a valuable experience.” Unfortunately for him, his junior colleague Jeff Sessions somehow escapes those pesky restrictions by offering “a stipend for our interns, provided in two payments, based on the Senate payroll schedule.”
Among the small group who offer payment, it’s often restricted to specific populations or under limited conditions. Virginia Democrat Tim Kaine and Kentucky Republican Rand Paul, for example, offer academic credit or a stipend, as if the two were mutually exclusive or provided the same benefit. Others, like Arkansas Democrat Mark Pryor and Oklahoma Republican James Inhofe, will pay in the summer but not the fall or spring. North Carolina’s Richard Burr and Nebraska’s Deb Fischer, both Republicans, offer the reverse.
Those interested in serving Kansas Republican Pat Roberts should hope it isn’t a sought-after position: He will pay when hosting two interns, but not more. Others divide their intern cohort, creating classes of paid and unpaid interns during the same period, and doing the same work. Pennsylvania Democrat Bob Casey offers two endowed internships, while the rest of his interns are volunteers. Thad Cochran, Republican of Mississippi, perhaps a bit more sensibly only pays interns from Mississippi colleges.
When senators do pay, the amount varies widely. North Dakota Republican John Hoeven has one of the many offices that offer a “small stipend to help defray living expenses.” A number of senators pay handsomely — or at least appropriately for the cost of living in Washington. Mike Enzi, a Wyoming Republican, and Mark Begich, an Alaska Democrat, publicize their reasonable rates of $1,600 and $1,500 per month, respectively. Contra Padron, the crowd-funded Reid intern, who claims that the “average housing in D.C. is $1,350 a month for a one person in the very, very modest of choices,” Enzi and Begich pay more than enough to find comfortable housing, transit, and food for a summer in Washington (I speak from personal experience).
It’s the Principles, Not Just the Cash
Beyond the details, nuances, and occasional absurdities of the different offices, two larger facts shouldn’t escape recognition.
First, nearly 70 senators ask their interns to perform a public service for free every summer. Over the same three-month period (August recess included), those senators earn $43,500 apiece. Needless to say, there is a distinct contrast between the leaders — many of whom are proud of their own previous internships — who perform “public service” for pay, and the youth they ask to do the same for free.
Second, and embarrassingly for Reid and the blue team, the vast majority of senators who do pay are Republicans. Of those 35 senators, only 11 are Democrats — meaning almost 80 percent of Dems require volunteer participation (not counting Bernie Sanders, an independent who caucuses with the Democrats). This is peculiar and troubling for a party that elsewhere signals its commitment to fair pay, equal representation, economic inequality, and workplace welfare. When it comes to interns in the Senate, it seems that traditional beliefs about labor and economic opportunity are suddenly switched. Despite frequently proposing and voting in favor of legislation that opens the workplace door to all Americans, Democrats ignore the same values when it comes to their interns. Reid’s office did not respond to requests for comments.*
Conversely, the ever budget-conscious GOP might consider taking a look at the extra expenses afforded to paid internships. One might argue that paying interns who would work for free is a prime example of “government waste.” Nonetheless, half of senate Republicans have decided to pay interns, and should perhaps earn some rare positive reinforcement from labor activists.
Unpaid internships, besides the intrinsic problem of failing to pay for work that is necessary to the Senate, are some of the stronger remnants of socio-economic stagnation. For those who can afford to pay out of pocket for a summer in Washington, or are lucky to win a rare grant or scholarship, a Hill internship is a crucial first toehold in the political establishment. Full-time work for no pay clashes with liberal values, but it does perpetuate the cycle of socioeconomic privilege. Until they align their actions with their stated political goals, Democrats will have to confront the better, if confusing, behavior of their Republican colleagues.
Even though Congress has exempted itself from the same legal requirements it imposes on the private sector, the contradiction with the laws they have set is glaring.
Setting a model for other sectors and industries can begin by a simple commitment to paid labor in their own offices. They need not sacrifice other priorities to do so. Thrifty budgeting allowed Rand Paul to both pay his interns and also return $500,000 to the Treasury last year. Senators, unlike House members, are also able to use excess campaign funds for “officially related expenses,” a prime pool of unallocated money that could go towards interns. The simplest solution is to apportion intern pay from “the Senator’s Account” meant for office salary and expenses.
As the intern debate rages on, looking to the operations on the Hill — in addition to the interns at the Department of Labor — will become ever more important to prospective legal changes in intern labor requirements, in Washington and beyond. In practice, as the profile of intern incidents gain traction, observing the status of our Capitol’s interns will be telling. As of now, though, a filibuster-proof bipartisan majority of senators — a true rarity — seems set on keeping their public servants for free. Senate interns are fixtures of Capitol life. It’s up to our leaders to decide if they will continue to treat them as furnishings, or something more.
* The White House doesn’t pay participants in its its exclusive internship program — despite President Obama’s stated commitment to youth and economic opportunity. The Fair Pay Campaign, a grassroots lobby set to start operations soon, is setting the White House Internship Program as a primary target. And that doesn’t even factor in the strands of nepotism reported by the Washington Post.via How the Senate Exploits Unpaid Interns – Politics – The Atlantic.
- Shocked, Shocked: The Senate Exploits Unpaid Interns (theatlantic.com)
- How the Senate Exploits Unpaid Interns (realclearpolitics.com)
- Wanted: Unpaid interns to work for free in the Senate. Oh yeah, it’s in DC, which isn’t cheap (shortformblog.com)
- Can’t afford an internship? Ask for donations (wyff4.com)
- Jessica Padron Launches Indiegogo Campaign To Finance Unpaid Internship With Harry Reid (huffingtonpost.com)
- Donations sought for unpaid internship (abc15.com)
- Harry Reid’s unpaid intern needs cash (cnn.com)
- Unpaid Senate Intern Uses Crowdfunding To Subsidize Internship (thinkprogress.org)
- Friday Five: Do Not Underestimate the Power of the Intern (prsay.prsa.org)