Chinese Officials Apologize for Gross Photoshop IneptitudePosted: November 1, 2013
Richard Silk reports: Shamed by a chorus of outrage and ridicule on social media, local officials in central China have apologized for a very shoddy piece of Photoshop work.
A picture posted online by the government of Ningguo, a small city in Anhui province, showed the deputy mayor and his colleagues towering above the city’s oldest resident while paying their respects to her at a festival earlier this month.
One-hundred-and-three-year-old Cheng Yanchun, looking smaller than a Hobbit, is squeezed into the bottom right hand corner of the image; next to her, a botched fade-out effect makes it look a little like the oversized local leaders have risen from the dead.
The picture has since been removed from the government’s website, but continues to float about on social media.
“After this incident occurred, the picture was reproduced on all the major web portals and this had a negative impact on our city,” said Ningguo’s government in one of several statements posted on its website Wednesday (in Chinese).
“For this reason, we have decided to publicly admonish the Civil Affairs Bureau and the person responsible, Xu Feiyu. We hope all departments will learn a lesson from this incident and be even more rigorous in checking the information they publish.”
Officials said they really did visit Ms. Cheng, but acknowledged that the picture was altered using Photoshop, a program that is used to manipulate images.
It isn’t the first time government personnel have been exposed after inept attempts to doctor an image. Two years ago, officials in Huili County in the southwestern province of Sichuan went to inspect a newly built road – but in photographs of the trip they appear to be floating high above the asphalt.
Internet wags lost no time in Photoshopping the proud visitors into a range of other landscapes, from the Apollo moon landing to a lake filled with dinosaurs.
This latest Photoshop snafu adds fuel to a smoldering cynicism about minor officials and their cack-handed publicity. It also comes in the midst of a “mass line” campaign launched new Chinese president Xi Jinping that aims to improve the Communist Party’s image among the people.
In an interview with state-run CCTV that aired Thursday morning, the culprit came clean. Mr. Xu, the director of the city’s Aging Office, was apparently motivated by nothing more than a desire to get everyone into the same photo.
“I thought this photo by itself didn’t really represent the occasion,” he said. “So I put the two pictures together. At the time I didn’t think there would be such a big reaction.”
Remembering that earlier screw-up, some netizens felt more inclined to forgive Mr. Xu and his colleagues in Ningguo.
“To be honest, it’s a lot better than that picture of those three morons on the road,” said a user identified as Che Luyao in comments on Zhihu.com, a news aggregator.
As in that previous case, Chinese Internet users helpfully posted examples of how to improve the doctored photo, with one proffering a retouched image that replaced Ms. Cheng with a scantily clad (and properly sized) model.
– Richard Silk
- Another Massive Photoshop Fail in China (tealeafnation.com)
- Greatest Photoshop fail? (smh.com.au)
- China officials in new Photoshop fail (theguardian.com)
- Another Chinese Photoshop Folly! (lunaticoutpost.com)
- Cropaganda: Anhui officials mocked for photoshopped PR photo (wantchinatimes.com)
- The Chinese government is really really bad at Photoshop (sploid.gizmodo.com)
- Another Massive Photoshop Fail in China (foreignpolicy.com)
- Photoshop Fail, People’s Republic of China edition (boingboing.net)
- Photoshop fail! Chinese officials tower over tiny old woman in bizarre government propaganda disaster (mirror.co.uk)
- Chinese officials’ photoshop attempt backfires (telegraph.co.uk)