Think Power InequalityPosted: February 4, 2014
Forget income inequality. Most of our money and clout goes to Washington.
For USATODAY, Jonah Goldberg writes: On my wife’s side, I have a very large family in Fairbanks, Alaska. Culturally, Fairbanks is a lot further from New York City (where I grew up) or Washington, D.C., (where I live now) than the several thousand miles on the map might suggest. Alaska wins a lot of comparisons, and not just the obvious ones such as physical beauty or salmon fishing. For instance, Alaska ranks second best in terms of economic equality (just behind Wyoming) while New York and the District of Columbia compete for dead last.
[Jonah Goldberg‘s book “The Tyranny of Cliches: How Liberals Cheat in the War of Ideas” is available at Amazon]
Frankly, I don’t much care about the issue of income inequality beyond its status as a symptom for real problems such as poor economic mobility, chronic unemployment and family breakdown. But lots of people do. President Obama even says it’s the “defining challenge of our time.” So it’s at least fun to note that Sarah Palin’s Alaska beats the competition.
In my experience, Alaska stands out in another way: social equality. When I started going there regularly, I was shocked to discover how casually different economic classes intermingle. Scanning the attendees of a party or patrons of a restaurant, it’s pretty much guesswork to figure out who’s a millionaire and who’s a mechanic. Nothing like that happens in places like Washington, New York or Los Angeles, where upper and lower classes get along little better than the Morlocks and Eloi did in H.G. Wells’ The Time Machine. But it does happen in lots of places — liberal and conservative — outside the Amtrak Acela corridor.
Sentiments top economics
Mickey Kaus, who has been writing about inequality for decades, recently argued in The Wall Street Journal that we should focus on social equality instead of economic equality. “When we think honestly about why we really hate growing inequality, I suspect it won’t boil down to economics but to sentiments. No, we don’t want to ‘punish success’ — the typical Democratic disclaimer. But we do want to make sure the rich don’t start feeling they’re better than the rest of us.”
I think Kaus’ diagnosis is largely right. There is a very real sense — from the “Occupy Left” to the “Tea Party Right” — that the system is being rigged from the top. Who is doing the rigging depends on whom you talk to.…
Jonah Goldberg, fellow at the American Enterprise Institute and National Reviewcontributing editor, is author of The Tyranny of Clichés, now out in paperback. He is also a member of USA TODAY’s Board of Contributors.
In addition to its own editorials, USA TODAY publishes diverse opinions from outside writers, including our Board of Contributors. To read more columns like this, go to the opinion front page or follow us on twitter @USATopinion orFacebook.
- MICKEY KAUS: The GOP’s Grandfather Weapon: I don’t quite understand the new, near-unanimous De… (pjmedia.com)
- MICKEY KAUS ON THE LATEST IMMIGRATION “REFORM” PROPOSAL: This is the best scam they can come up wit… (pjmedia.com)
- MICKEY KAUS: Boehner’s Bad Date With Amnesty. It sure looks like Speaker Boehner had a Bad Date … (pjmedia.com)
- The Left Talks a Great Deal About the Evils of Income Inequality, But Is Very Happy to Perpetuate a Regime of Social Inequality (minx.cc)
- Inequality fight: Let’s start with Obama’s policies (hotair.com)
- On Inequality, Voters Aren’t Buying the Democrats’ Solution (powerlineblog.com)
- Income Inequality Continued: The Fight Against Income Inequality (petersonjet.wordpress.com)
- Seattle’s income inequality “not as bad as you think,” plus bonus links on mobility and the minimum wage (researchcouncil.org)
- Narrowing the Gap on Income Inequality (aspanational.wordpress.com)