Transparency: Despite Vows of Help, White House Withholds Thousands of Documents from Senate CIA ProbePosted: March 12, 2014
For McClatchy DC, Jonathan s. Landay, Ali Watkins, and Marisa Taylor report: The White House has been withholding for five years more than 9,000 top-secret documents sought by the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence for its investigation into the now-defunct CIA detention and interrogation program, even though President Barack Obama hasn’t exercised a claim of executive privilege.
“The most nefarious explanation is that they are not privileged and the White House simply doesn’t want to hand them over…”
— Elizabeth Goitein
In contrast to public assertions that it supports the committee’s work, the White House has ignored or rejected offers in multiple meetings and in letters to find ways for the committee to review the records, a McClatchy investigation has found.
“…Executive privilege is generally asserted after negotiations and brinksmanship behind the scenes. People put on paper what they want to be formalized, and these negotiations by their very nature are very informal.”
— Elizabeth Goitein
The significance of the materials couldn’t be learned. But the administration’s refusal to turn them over or to agree to any compromise raises questions about what they would reveal about the CIA’s use of waterboarding and other harsh interrogation techniques on suspected terrorists in secret overseas prisons.
The dispute indicates that the White House is more involved than it has acknowledged in the unprecedented power struggle between the committee and the CIA, which has triggered charges that the agency searched the panel’s computers without authorization and has led to requests to the Justice Department for criminal investigations of CIA personnel and Senate aides.
[Elizabeth Goitein is the co-director of the Brennan Center for Justice’s Liberty and National Security Program]
“These documents certainly raise the specter that the White House has been involved in stonewalling the investigation,” said Elizabeth Goitein, the co-director of the Brennan Center for Justice’s Liberty and National Security Program at the New York University Law School.
The committee and the CIA declined to comment.
In a statement to McClatchy, the White House confirmed that “a small percentage” of the 6.2 million pages of documents provided to the committee were “set aside because they raise executive branch confidentiality interests.”
The White House also said that it had worked closely with the committee “to ensure access to the information necessary to review the CIA’s former program.”
Speaking to reporters earlier during a White House event, Obama said that the administration has worked with the committee to ensure that its study is “well informed” and that he was committed to seeing the report declassified once a final version is completed. He said it wouldn’t be proper for him to comment directly on the battle between the CIA and the committee, except to say that CIA Director John Brennan had referred the issues to the “appropriate authorities and they are looking into it.”
The Democrat-controlled committee has largely kept silent about the tussle with the White House, even as some members have decried what they contend has been the CIA’s refusal to surrender key materials on the agency’s use under the Bush administration of interrogation methods denounced by the panel chairwoman as “un-American” and “brutal.”
The chairwoman, Sen. Dianne Feinstein of California, made no mention of the White House documents during a blistering floor speech Tuesday in which she charged that the CIA may have undermined the Constitution and violated the law by searching computers used by her staff to compile the study. Brennan has denied her allegations and the White House has expressed continued confidence in his leadership of the CIA….Read the rest >>>
Lesley Clark and William Douglas of the Washington Bureau contributed.
Email: firstname.lastname@example.org, email@example.com, firstname.lastname@example.org.
- CIA may have broken law, undermined Constitution, Sen. Feinstein charges (star-telegram.com)
- Senate Intelligence head accuses CIA of undermining US “constitutional framework” (counterinformation.wordpress.com)
- Senate Intelligence Head accuses CIA of Undermining US “Constitutional Framework” (therebel.org)
- CIA violates United States constitution, Senator Feinstein says (dearkitty1.wordpress.com)
- CIA may have broken law, undermined Constitution, Sen. Feinstein charges (kansas.com)
- CIA may have broken law, undermined Constitution, Sen. Feinstein charges (kansascity.com)
- CIA Spied on Senate Committee Investigating CIA (sitehighway.com)
- Udall at center of Senate-CIA spat (politico.com)