Reality Check: There is No Moral Equivalency Between Israel and HamasPosted: July 15, 2014 | |
For the New York Post, Charles Schumer writes: Amid the recent troubles between Israel and the Palestinians, many Americans and media commentators are drawing disturbing lines of parallelism between the two societies, asserting a false moral equivalency to the actions of each.
“How did Hamas and too many diverse parts of the mainstream Palestinian community respond to the kidnap and murder of three young Israelis? They cheered.”
In essence, the claim goes like this: “Both sides are fighting each other with similar degrees of violence; both treat each other equally badly; each side is equally to blame for the violence, and they just can’t come together.”
“And is it no wonder, given the vitriolic hatred of Israel that has been preached in textbooks and schools to two generations of Palestinian children.”
That notion that there is a moral equivalency between the defensive and targeted actions that the rule-of-law-based Israel is compelled to take, and the proactive and indiscriminate actions that hate-based organizations like Hamas takes, is completely unfair, unfounded and infuriating to supporters of Israel — with good reason.
“Such propaganda has….created a perverse mythology throughout Palestinian society that calls suicide bombers “martyrs” and extols kidnappers and murderers as heroes.”
In fact, there is no moral equivalence between the actions and reactions of Israel and Hamas and the Palestinian community to the violence that has occurred.
Two glaring examples stand out. The first revolves around the difference between Israel’s and the Palestinian community’s reactions to the horrible kidnappings and coldblooded murders of four boys, three Israeli and one Palestinian.
No doubt the loss of these children is one beyond words. Both incidents were abhorrent.
But the reaction on both sides was not the same. How did Hamas and too many diverse parts of the mainstream Palestinian community respond to the kidnap and murder of three young Israelis? They cheered….(read more)
- International Analysis – Shattering Myths: The Conflict between Israel and Hamas (peruviantimes.com)
- So Much for That Israel-Hamas Ceasefire (mediaite.com)
- Free Gaza… From Hamas (breitbart.com)
- Israel crisis: Obama’s obscene moral relativism (oddonion.com)
- Palestinian Delusions Fuel Conflict (commentarymagazine.com)
- Israel’s New Challenge: Defeating The Third Intifada (joshuapundit.blogspot.com)
- Israel Remains Remarkably Moral (algemeiner.com)
- 4 Myths About The Latest Israel-Hamas Conflict (dailycaller.com)