Hong Kong: Democracy Vote SuspendedPosted: October 27, 2014 | |
For WSJ, Isabella Steger reports: Four weeks after volleys of tear gas by police led thousands of protesters to seize control of streets across Hong Kong, the leaders of the pro-democracy movement are struggling to control its disparate groups as fatigue and frustration set in.
On Sunday, a split among the protest groups led to the abrupt cancellation of a two-day vote on the latest offer by city officials, just hours before it was set to begin. Some protesters criticized the vote saying the groups organizing it didn’t represent them.
‘“In this movement, I’m motivated by myself, not the leadership.”’
—Bonnie Kong, 30
“I admit the [leaders] have made a mistake,” said Alex Chow, secretary-general of the Hong Kong Federation of Students. “We look forward to having more discussions with protesters in the three protest sites.”
He linked hands with other key figures from the three groups leading the protests and bowed in apology. Joshua Wong, the 18-year-old leader of one of the two student groups, asked for protesters’ forgiveness, and all admitted that the decision to hold the vote was hasty and lacked preparation.
“Without [a united front] the protest groups can’t consolidate power and there is no structure for discussions, let alone making decisions.”
— Leung Kwok-hung, chairman of the League of Social Democrats
Bonnie Kong, 30, who works in media sales, said she accepted the leaders’ apology but said they didn’t represent her. “We don’t follow the leadership,” she said. “In this movement, I’m motivated by myself, not the leadership.”
The city’s government, which has refused to meet their demands, is hoping that public opinion turns against the students. Groups of opponents to the protesters, wearing blue ribbons in support of the police, carried out a petition drive and held rallies over the weekend.
“The most resilient aspect of this movement is the unity of the protesters. There is no ‘organizer’ in this movement. Each time the crowds swelled, was it because ‘organizers’ asked people to come out or was it because of something the government did?”
— Keita Lee, 28, a cook, who expects the occupation of Admiralty to last at least until the Lunar New Year in February
On Sunday evening, Carrie Lam, the government official who led the one meeting with students, called for more talks. “Our community expects the government and the student representatives to hold more dialogues in order to as soon as possible get out of the current impasse,” Ms. Lam said in a TV interview.
Besides tear gas and pepper spray, the protesters have endured attacks from opponents and efforts by police and others to clear the roads they occupy in three densely populated districts of Hong Kong, including the main protest site surrounding the city government headquarters. Those actions have galvanized the protesters, drawing out large crowds whenever the movement was under attack.
But time is starting to take its toll. As protesters and the government are in a stalemate, the three main protest groups—the Hong Kong Federation of Students, a second student group known as Scholarism and Occupy Central, founded by college professors—must now contend with practical and difficult decisions about what next steps to take. Many protesters are becoming weary, mistrustful, or physically drained. Some have returned to school after a university class boycott that began Sep. 22.
“There are internal differences, but I wouldn’t say there’s fighting,” said Leung Kwok-hung, chairman of the League of Social Democrats, an opposition political party that has backed the protests.
But he said the group needed to coordinate better. “Without [a united front] the protest groups can’t consolidate power and there is no structure for discussions, let alone making decisions,” Mr. Leung said.
Protest leaders called for the vote Friday, three days after the one face-to-face session they had with city officials. The government repeated its rejection of their demand that Hong Kong’s next leader be chosen directly by the public, saying a decision by Beijing that the candidates must be approved to run couldn’t be reversed….(read more)
—Ned Levin and Fiona Law contributed to this article.
- Hong Kong to investigate alleged police beating (edition.cnn.com)
- Alleged beating stuns Hong Kong (cnn.com)
- Hong Kong Pro-Democracy Protesters Split After Call to Retreat (punditfromanotherplanet.com)
- Beijing Blinks: Hong Kong Leader Leung Chun-ying Offers Talks with Protesters as He Refuses to Accept Calls for Him to Resign (punditfromanotherplanet.com)
- Hong Kong Readies for Protester Vote (punditfromanotherplanet.com)