Obama’s Immigration Executive Order is a Confession of Democratic FailurePosted: November 22, 2014
Evidently the harder path was just too hard
Michael Gerson writes: There are any number of marvelous things one might do as president, if Congress were not such a checked and balanced mess. But future presidents now have a new method at their disposal: Declare a long-running debate to be a national emergency. Challenge Congress, under threat of unilateral executive action, to legislate on the topic before your term runs out. And when lawmakers refuse, act with the most expansive definition of presidential power.
The supporting arguments for this approach come down to the claim that the American political system is broken — incapable of action on urgent matters because of obstructionism, bad faith and the abuse of legislative procedure. It is the political philosophy of “something must be done.”
“By crossing this particular Rubicon, Obama has given up on politics, which is, from one perspective, understandable. He doesn’t do it well.”
The arguments against this approach often come down to institutionalism. Major policy shifts, in this view, deserve legislative hearings and an open amendment process. The White House should make its views known and issue veto threats. There should be a negotiation between the House and Senate to reconcile a bill. There should be a presidential signature, or a veto and an override debate. The machinery is admittedly creaky, but it manufactures democratic legitimacy.
President Obama has ably and sequentially defended both these positions. A year ago, during another immigration speech, a heckler insisted, “You have a power to stop deportations.” Obama replied: “Actually, I don’t, and that’s why we’re here. . . . What you need to know, when I’m speaking as president of the United States and I come to this community, is that if, in fact, I could solve all these problems without passing laws in Congress, then I would do so. But we’re also a nation of laws. That’s part of our tradition. And so the easy way out is to try to yell and pretend like I can do something by violating our laws. And what I’m proposing is the harder path, which is to use our democratic processes to achieve the same goal that you want to achieve.”
Obama has now officially abandoned the harder path — not because the issues surrounding immigration will never be resolved (a case no one has adequately made) but because he wants to be the president to resolve them….(read more)
- Immigration amnesty by executive order (patheos.com)
- Immigration reform battle is about to get ugly (bbc.co.uk)
- White House Communications Director Jennifer Palmieri: Obama’s executive amnesty doesn’t tear up the Constitution (thepunditpress.com)
- WHITE HOUSE: Boehner Can Go F**k Himself, Dictator Obama Will Grant Amnesty! (americasfreedomfighters.com)
- Get your earplugs ready (mindofbrosephus.wordpress.com)
- Susan Page: Obama ‘More Dangerous’ to Press than Any Admin in ‘American History’ (breitbart.com)
- Text of the White House Fact Sheet on Obama’s Immigration Action (blogs.wsj.com)