Gordon Crovitz: Defending Satire to the DeathPosted: January 11, 2015
Moderate Muslims are most in need of a robust defense of free speech, especially if it offends
L. Gordon Crovitz writes: ‘I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it,” wrote biographer Evelyn Beatrice Hall, summing up the view of her subject, Voltaire. The 17th-century French writer has been on many minds since last week’s Islamist atrocity in Paris. “As the news of the massacre sank in,” wrote historian Robert Darnton for the New York Review of Books, “I kept thinking of Voltaire and calling up his famous grin—lips curled and lower jaw stuck out, as if to defy anyone who might dare to pull a punch.”
“Moderate Muslims around the world most need a robust defense of free speech, especially if it offends. In the spirit of Voltaire, they’re taking great risks to challenge extremism.”
Many of us don’t share the sensibilities of Charlie Hebdo’s leftist politics and sometimes juvenile humor, but the terrorists who massacred its staff attacked a core component of French identity. “Free thought begetting light-hearted satire . . . is at the root of French character,” observed a 19th-century British history of French literature. French-style caustic satire is less common in the Anglosphere, but the Enlightenment in all forms enrages Islamists.
“Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities.”
In the 18th century, Voltaire was exiled and jailed and had his books burned. He sought ecrasez l’infame—to crush the infamous—by which he meant most forms of authority. He called Christianity “assuredly the most ridiculous, the most absurd and the most bloody religion which has ever infected this world.” He criticized Judaism and Islam. “Superstition sets the whole world in flames,” he observed. “Philosophy quenches them.”
“The many ‘Je suis Charlie’ signs and social-media hashtags show that popular support for free speech is ahead of politically correct university administrators and politicians. Brandeis University last year shamefully canceled an honorary degree for van Gogh’s Muslim associate on the film, Ayaan Hirsi Ali.”
Charlie Hebdo inherited that tradition. The Catholic Church has sued it more than a dozen times. Its murdered editor, Stephane Charbonnier, had said he hoped to carry on “until Islam is just as banal as Catholicism.” One cover featured a fundamentalist Muslim, an Orthodox Jew and the pope shouting in unison: “Charlie Hebdo must be veiled!”
Islamists can’t abide free speech. They issued a death sentence for Salman Rushdie for writing a novel, forced a Danish cartoonist into hiding, and murdered Theo van Gogh in Amsterdam for making a film.
The many “Je suis Charlie” signs and social-media hashtags show that popular support for free speech is ahead of politically correct university administrators and politicians. Brandeis University last year shamefully canceled an honorary degree for van Gogh’s Muslim associate on the film, Ayaan Hirsi Ali. President Obama legitimized Islamist complaints by telling the United Nations in 2012: “The future must not belong to those who slander the prophet of Islam.” The same year Mr. Obama’s spokesman, Jay Carney , criticized Charlie Hebdo for a cartoon depicting a naked Muhammad: “We have questions about the judgment of publishing something like this.” It’s wiser for universities and governments to invoke free speech than to second-guess editorial decisions.
Not that every editorial decision is right….(read more)
- The Brandeis University Debacle (americanthinker.com)
- Student gets death threats for publicizing liberal tweets (grumpyelder.com)
- We stand with those who bleed because of the truths they told (bangordailynews.com)
- Joe Biden To Ayaan Hirsi Ali: “Let me tell you one or two things about Islam.” (joshuapundit.blogspot.com)
- Clinically Braindead Brandeis Students Stand Up For Racist Khadijah Lynch, Woman Who Has “No Sympathy” For Dead NYPD Cops (downtrend.com)
- A College Essay (blogs.timesofisrael.com)
- Bill Maher: ‘Islam Is The Problem’ (dailycaller.com)
- Brandeis reverses itself on honorary degree to Ayaan Hirsi Ali (powerlineblog.com)
- Brandeis’s disgrace (powerlineblog.com)
- Brandeis University Rescinds Ayaan Hirsi Ali’s Honorary Degree (nationalreview.com)