FAKENEWSAMAGGEDON: Yasmin Seweid’s Hijab Hate Hoax Vexes New York Daily NewsPosted: December 15, 2016 Filed under: Breaking News, Crime & Corruption, Mediasphere, Politics, Religion, Terrorism | Tags: 2016 Nice attack, Andrew Cuomo, Barack Obama, Bill de Blasio, Daily News (New York), Donald Trump, Gateway Pundit, Grand Central Terminal, Hillary Clinton, Imam, Muslim, New York, New York City, New York City Police Department, Queens, Trump Tower (New York City) 1 Comment
Baruch College student Yasmin Seweid, we now know, was not herself the victim of a hate crime. She made it all up. But by telling the tale of her attack by men shouting “Trump,” ripping at her hijab, while a trainful of New Yorkers sat silent, she victimized many others.
First on the list: the New York Police Department, which spent precious resources chasing a fabricated assault. Cops tried to track down witnesses — there were none. They reviewed video for clues — there were none.
[ALSO SEE – Look At This Chilling Picture Of Yasmin Seweid, The Day After Her Arrest – redstate.com]
Next: her fellow New Yorkers, who did not in fact stand idly by while watching a woman be attacked because of her faith. We are not the city of Kitty Genovese; that story of passive witness to horror, so many years ago, was itself a myth. But the image persists that New Yorkers are a can’t-be-bothered-even-if-you’re-in-danger lot. It’s a lie.
Count among the wronged President-elect Donald Trump, who did not inspire three drunk men to home in on a vulnerable target who looked different from them. Read the rest of this entry »
Washington Post: ‘Don’t Look Now, but Fox News is Doing a Very Good Job of Covering the Republican Primary’Posted: December 18, 2015 Filed under: Breaking News, Mediasphere, Politics, U.S. News, White House | Tags: Andrew Cuomo, Barack Obama, CNN, Donald Trump, Marco Rubio, Megyn Kelly, Muslim, Republican Party (United States), Ted Cruz, The Washington Post, United States Leave a comment
Fox News ‘Very Tough’ on Republican Front-Runners
Callum Borchers reports: There was a moment in Tuesday’s Republican presidential debate when Donald Trump, as is his custom, complained about unfair lines of questioning.
[Read the full story here, at The Washington Post]
In an interview with Trump less than 24 hours later, Fox News host Bill O’Reilly gave the GOP front-runner another chance to air his grievances with CNN, which broadcast and moderated the rhetorical showdown from Las Vegas.
But Trump didn’t want to gripe about CNN anymore. He wanted to knock Fox, instead.
O’REILLY: Do you think CNN dislikes you — the news organization itself?
TRUMP: Well, honestly, I think I get better press from CNN than I do Fox, Bill, if you want to know the truth.
O’REILLY: Well, that’s because we’re the toughest network.
Laugh all you want, Fox haters, but O’Reilly might be right — at least as far as the 2016 Republican presidential primary goes.
You’d have to be in a Rumpelstiltskin-esque slumber not to know that Trump has been carping about Fox coverage for months now. The thing that really set him off was a debate question in August from Fox News host Megyn Kelly, who confronted him about his propensity for ad hominem attacks on women. That, of course, led Trump to remark the next day that Kelly had “blood coming out of her wherever” — a perfect confirmation of her question’s premise — and Trump has continued to blast Kelly and the network ever since.
Now, it’s certainly true that Trump has targeted seemingly every media outlet for ridicule, at some point. And making a candidate unhappy isn’t the same as covering him well.
But Fox has gotten under Trump’s skin more often than most, with tough questionsand reasonable critiques on proposals like blocking all Muslims from entering the United States and building a wall along the Southern border to keep out Mexicans. Read the rest of this entry »
Why Uber Drives the Left CrazyPosted: July 27, 2015 Filed under: Crime & Corruption, U.S. News | Tags: Andrew Cuomo, Ashton Kutcher, Bailout, Barack Obama, Bill de Blasio, Boris Johnson, Cartel, Deputy mayor, Kate Upton, Mayor, New York, New York City, Uber (company) 1 Comment
Why New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio’s attempt to protect a government-enforced cartel ran out of gas
L. Gordon Crovitz writes: Progressive New York Mayor Bill de Blasio and Socialist Paris Mayor Anne Hidalgofound common cause on a shared threat while attending a recent climate-change conference at the Vatican. “The people of our cities don’t like the notion of those who are particularly wealthy and powerful dictating the terms to a government elected by the people,” Mr. de Blasio declared. “As a multibillion-dollar company, Uber thinks it can dictate to government.”
“Uber made the fight personal by adding a ‘de Blasio’ mode to its app, estimating how long the wait would be under the proposed law. Model Kate Upton tweeted in Uber’s support.”
But before Mr. de Blasio could return from Rome, he learned that people really don’t like when politicians try to take away their favorite app for getting around the government’s taxi cartel. The mayor was forced to drop his plan to limit Uber to a 1% annual increase in cars, far below the current rate.
“Errol Louis wrote in the Daily News that ‘Mayor de Blasio is leaving N.Y.ers stranded—like a black man trying to hail a cab uptown.’”
It’s hard to see why Mr. de Blasio thought that would be good politics. Two million New Yorkers have downloaded the Uber app onto their mobile devices—a quarter of the city’s population and more than twice the number of citizens who voted for Mr. de Blasio. But it’s easy to understand why he views Uber as an ideological threat. A tipping point is in sight where big-government politicians can no longer deprive consumers of new choice made possible by technology—whether for car rides, car sharing or home rentals. Mr. de Blasio’s experience should encourage other politicians to sign up for innovation.
“You are dealing with a huge economic force which is consumer choice, and the taxi trade needs to recognize that…I’m afraid it is a tragic fact that there are now more than a million people in this city who have the Uber app.’”
— The Conservative mayor of London, Boris Johnson
Uber has become a wedge issue. The Conservative mayor of London, Boris Johnson, took the opposite approach from Mr. de Blasio. “You are dealing with a huge economic force which is consumer choice, and the taxi trade needs to recognize that,” he said recently. He told a gathering of taxi drivers in London: “I’m afraid it is a tragic fact that there are now more than a million people in this city who have the Uber app.” When cabbies objected that Uber drivers were undercutting their prices, Mr. Johnson replied: “Yes, they are. It’s called the free market.”
“Government-enforced cartels fall faster and harder to disruptive innovation than most businesses. When change comes, it is more dramatic than in industries that already have competition.”
Presidential candidates are divided as well. Hillary Clinton implicitly criticized Uber in her campaign speech on economic policy, saying the “so-called ‘gig economy’ ” is “raising hard questions about workplace protections and what a good job will look like.” Read the rest of this entry »
TRENDING! Licking Other People’s StuffPosted: July 10, 2015 Filed under: Entertainment, Humor, Mediasphere, Politics | Tags: Abortion debate, Academy Award, Adoption, American's Creed, Andrew Cuomo, Ariana Grande, BEN SHAPIRO, doughnuts, Fight Club, Rihanna, Same-sex marriage, Susan Sarandon, Thelma & Louise Leave a comment
On Thursday, actress Susan Sarandon, most famous for citrusing her breasts in Atlantic City and driving off a cliff in Thelma and Louise, came out in support of pop brat doughnut-licker Ariana Grande
Grande was caught on tape badmouthing America after spreading her saliva on doughnuts on display; she justified that action the next day, claiming she had to fight childhood obesity by surreptitiously tonguing the sugary products. Now, Sarandon has tweeted:
Today, lick a doughnut in solidarity with @ArianaGrande. A sweet, talented, true American. 🍩🇺🇸
— Susan Sarandon (@SusanSarandon) July 9, 2015
Never mind the illogic of Grande’s contention that she secretly licked doughnuts to discourage others from eating them – if she truly wanted to discourage others, she could have stomped on them publicly, or called for a nationwide boycott of doughnuts, or cut a new version of “Problem” in which Iggy Azalea raps about moving beyond doughy joy. Focus instead on the nihilism of defacing someone else’s property without their knowledge. It takes a special kind of emptiness to do something like that.
[Read the full text here, at Breitbart]
But the left is fine with that sort of behavior so long as the target is someone who hasn’t bought into leftist thought. That’s undoubtedly why Grande wrote that her doughnut-licking represented a crusade against big, bad American fatties:
As an advocate for healthy eating, food is very important to me and I sometimes get upset by how freely we as Americans eat and consume things without giving any thought to the consequences that it has on our health and society as a whole. The fact that the United States has the highest child obesity rate in the world frustrates me.
Read the rest of this entry »
Politicians who Campaign Against Cops are Inviting MayhemPosted: December 22, 2014 Filed under: Crime & Corruption, Politics | Tags: Al Sharpton, Andrew Cuomo, Barack Obama, Bill de Blasio, Brooklyn, Eric Holder, New York, New York City, New York City Police Department, United States Attorney General, William J. Bratton 1 Comment
Progressives and the Police
‘What do we want? Dead cops!” So chanted marchers at one of the protests organized in the last month against the failure of grand juries to indict white officers in the death of black crime suspects Michael Brown and Eric Garner. On Saturday they got their wish, as a black assailant citing revenge for Brown and Garner traveled from Maryland to murder two cops sitting in their patrol car in Brooklyn.
“America is full of Brinsleys who no longer abide the norms of civilized behavior, if they even know what those norms are. They need but the slightest excuse to take justice into their own hands and go on a rampage.”
“They were quite simply assassinated, targeted for their uniform,” New York Police Commissioner William Bratton said, and so they were. Garner and Brown were resisting arrest, but the two young officers never had a chance even to pull their guns. They had been marked for death near a high-crime housing project they were trying to protect against criminal predators.
“Especially in urban America, the police walk that line between civilization and mayhem every day.”
Mayor Bill de Blasio , Attorney General Eric Holder and President Obama were all quick to condemn the shooting. And let’s stipulate that no one other than the alleged shooter, Ismaaiyl Brinsley, is responsible for pulling the trigger. Chased into the subway by police, he then shot himself. Read the rest of this entry »
Fleeing Democrats Will Turn Texas BluePosted: March 22, 2014 Filed under: Politics, U.S. News | Tags: Andrew Cuomo, California, Democratic, Democrats, Illinois, Jerry Brown, Joel Pollak, New York, Texas Leave a comment
Joel B. Pollak reports: In Los Angeles this week, three city council members blamed fracking for an earthquake, though they are not actually certain whether any fracking has occurred. In New York, Mayor Bill de Blasio is continuing his fight to crush charter schools that are primarily helping black and Hispanic children. In Illinois, the House Speaker announced plans to raise taxes on millionaires, despite proof that doing so will hurt the state’s ailing economy.
Even some Democrats know that their party is being unreasonable.
California’s Gov. Jerry Brown, for example, refuses to ban fracking. New York’s Gov. Andrew Cuomo may hate conservatives just as much as de Blasio, but he is defending the charter schools. In Illinois, there aren’t yet any Democrats willing to oppose the millionaire tax. Yet millions of Democrats are voting with their feet, leaving Illinois for more conservative jurisdictions.
And perhaps that is the point.
Texas is the number-one destination for California’s émigré population, for example. It is popular among migrants from other blue states as well, owing to its warm climate, job opportunities, and lack of a state income tax. Over time, that is changing Texas’s political culture.
For years, Democrats have hoped to take Texas back. The Lone Star State has produced the last two Republican presidents, some of the most important conservative legislators, and untold millions of dollars for GOP candidates across the country. Read the rest of this entry »
SAFE Act Fail: New Yorkers Gather, Burn Nearly a Thousand Gun Registration FormsPosted: March 18, 2014 Filed under: Self Defense, U.S. News | Tags: Andrew Cuomo, Assault weapon, New York, New York State Police, NY SAFE Act, Right to keep and bear arms, The Saratogian, Twitter Leave a comment
Awr Hawkins reports: On March 16, SAFE Act protesters gathered in Saratoga, New York and burned “nearly a thousand gun registration forms.”
Postar.com reports the forms “are used for people to register with New York State Police firearms that meet the state’s definition of military-style assault weapons.”
The Saratogian reports that “hundreds of gun rights advocates” turned out for the rally, which turned out to be “equal parts a rally against Gov. Andrew Cuomo and a teach-in on how to not comply with [the] SAFE Act assault weapons registration law.”
The latter consisted of showing gun owners how to make lawful cosmetic changes to their AR-15s in order to keep them legal….Read more…
Regulation Migration: Gun Companies Continue to Move Operations to Southern StatesPosted: February 18, 2014 Filed under: Economics, Guns and Gadgets | Tags: Andrew Cuomo, Beretta, Bill Haslam, Connecticut, Magpul Industries, New York, Tennessee, Terry McAuliffe, Texas 4 Comments
AWRHawkins reports: What started as a slow trickle when American Tactical Imports (ATI) and PTR moved from the northeast to South Carolina, has now become an all out surge with Magpul Industries leaving Colorado, Beretta leaving Maryland for Tennessee, and Remington acquiring a 500,000 square ft. facility in Alabama.
[See also: Work begins at Horry County’s first firearms manufacturer]
As Breitbart News previously reported, Governor Andrew Cuomo‘s (D) SAFE Act drove ATI from New York in October while Governor Dannel Malloy‘s (D) draconian gun control drove PTR from Connecticut in June.
[Order The Enlightenment in America (Galaxy Books) from Amazon]
In early 2013 Magpul made it clear they were leaving Colorado if the state’s Democrat legislators passed a ban on “high capacity” magazines. The legislators passed the ban anyway, and on January 2, 2014 Breitbart News reported that Magpul was moving manufacturing to Wyoming and its corporate headquarters to Texas.
Do We See a Pattern Here? New York Passes Gun Control, NRA Membership SkyrocketsPosted: February 10, 2014 Filed under: Law & Justice, Self Defense | Tags: Andrew Cuomo, anti-gun, Gun laws, National Rifle Association, New York, New York State Rifle & Pistol Association, NY SAFE Act, Texas, Twitter 3 Comments
Katie McHugh reports: Membership in a New York affiliate of the National Rifle Association nearly doubled in a year after Democratic Gov. Andrew Cuomo passed harsh gun control measures in the wake of last year’s Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting.
New York now boasts 41,000 NRA members, up from the 22,000 members in January 2013, making it the largest NRA affiliate chapter in the country — surpassing even Texas.
How To ‘Fulfill Your Dreams’? Have an AbortionPosted: January 22, 2014 Filed under: Politics, U.S. News, White House | Tags: Andrew Cuomo, Barack Obama, Bill Clinton, George W. Bush, New York, Obama, Remnick, Robert Gates, Wendy Davis 1 Comment
No longer punished with a baby.
Ace also has a take on Isaac Chotiner‘s New Republic ‘Obama’s-talking-to-us-like-we’re-children’ complaint, which he gets to, further in. Read it all, at the HQ. Here’s Ace getting warmed up…
It’s instructive to note the shift from Bill Clinton to Barack Obama. Bill Clinton straddled the issue, rhetorically, by declaring that abortion should be “safe, legal, and rare.” By adding the last word — really nothing more than a rhetorical fillip, because he opposed all restrictions — he at least attempted to signal to pro-life people that he understood the act of abortion did in fact have moral consequences.
Whether he did believe this I have no idea. But he did at least try to signal his understanding of, and concern about, the moral consequences of abortion.
His political posture was thus: If you’re pro-life, I am voting against you; I will use my power as President to advance the interests of your opponents and thwart your own; however, I will at least give you the courtesy of a rhetorical nod towards the plausibility and respectability of your position. I disagree with you, but I will grant you that your position is well-founded, even if it is one I do not favor.
Compare this to Barack Obama, who today proclaims abortion an unambiguous moral good, something that permits “everyone” to “have the same freedom and opportunity to pursue their dreams.”
Cuomo the IntolerantPosted: January 22, 2014 Filed under: Mediasphere, Politics, U.S. News | Tags: Andrew Cuomo, Cuomo, Jonah Goldberg, National Review, New York, Tribune Media Services, Twitter, United States 4 Comments
The New York governor’s recent remarks show just how close-minded liberals can be
Jonah Goldberg writes: On paper, “liberal intolerance” is something of an oxymoron, like “jumbo shrimp,” “loyal opposition,” or “conspicuous absence.” But what makes oxymorons funny is that they are real things. There are jumbo shrimp. Absences can be conspicuous, opponents can be loyal, and liberals can be staggeringly and myopically intolerant.
[Amazon has Jonah Goldberg‘s fine book: The Tyranny of Cliches: How Liberals Cheat in the War of Ideas]
Last Friday, in a public-radio interview, New York governor Andrew Cuomo offered the sort of potted analysis of the national Republican party one would expect from an MSNBC talk show. But he went a bit further. After nodding to the fact that, historically, the New York state Republican party has been the most ideologically gelded of the breed (it is the birthplace of Rockefeller Republicanism, after all), Cuomo proclaimed that “extreme conservatives” have “no place in the state of New York.”
Who are extreme conservatives? People who are “right-to-life, pro–assault weapon, anti-gay.”
Sheriffs Refuse to Enforce Laws on Gun ControlPosted: December 16, 2013 Filed under: Guns and Gadgets, Law & Justice, Politics, Self Defense, U.S. News | Tags: Andrew Cuomo, Colorado, Gun politics, Jerry Brown, New York, Sheriff, Sheriff John 2 Comments
GREELEY, Colo. — Erica Goode writes: When Sheriff John Cooke of Weld County explains in speeches why he is not enforcing the state’s new gun laws, he holds up two 30-round magazines. One, he says, he had before July 1, when the law banning the possession, sale or transfer of the large-capacity magazines went into effect. The other, he “maybe” obtained afterward.
He shuffles the magazines, which look identical, and then challenges the audience to tell the difference.
“How is a deputy or an officer supposed to know which is which?” he asks.
Colorado’s package of gun laws, enacted this year after mass shootings in Aurora, Colo., and Newtown, Conn., has been hailed as a victory by advocates of gun control. But if Sheriff Cooke and a majority of the other county sheriffs in Colorado offer any indication, the new laws — which mandate background checks for private gun transfers and outlaw magazines over 15 rounds — may prove nearly irrelevant across much of the state’s rural regions.
Some sheriffs, like Sheriff Cooke, are refusing to enforce the laws, saying that they are too vague and violate Second Amendment rights. Many more say that enforcement will be “a very low priority,” as several sheriffs put it. All but seven of the 62 elected sheriffs in Colorado signed on in May to a federal lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of the statutes.
CHILL: NYPD Sending Out Gun Confiscation Letters to Law Abiding CitizensPosted: December 1, 2013 Filed under: Guns and Gadgets, Law & Justice, Self Defense, U.S. News | Tags: Andrew Cuomo, Confiscation, Gun, Gun control, Gun rights, New York, New York City Police Department, NY SAFE Act, NYPD, Second Amendment, Second Amendment Foundation 5 Comments
Law abiding citizens with legally registered guns are receiving letters from the NYPD ordering them to surrender their firearm.
Who is not receiving the letters? Gangbangers with illegal guns.
- It’s True: Government is Aggressively Engaged in Gun Confiscation In the US (disasterresponseteamofamerica.wordpress.com)
- It’s True: Government is Aggressively Engaged in Gun Confiscation In the US (freedomoutpost.com)
- It’s True: Government is Aggressively Engaged in Gun Confiscation In the US (silveristhenew.com)
- It’s True: The Government is Aggressively Confiscating Guns Throughout the U.S. (bobusnr.wordpress.com)
- The Gun Confiscation Notice an NYC Resident Reportedly Received Will Likely Send Chills Down Your Spine (govtslaves.info)
- The GUN CONFISCATION NOTICE AN NYC RESIDENT REPORTEDLY RECEIVED WILL SEND CHILLS DOWN YOUR SPINE! (thelastgreatstand.com)
- The Gun Confiscation Notice an NYC Resident Reportedly Received Will Likely Send Chills Down Your Spine (bobusnr.wordpress.com)
- RNhunter liked Robin’s discussion The Gun Confiscation Notice an NYC Resident Reportedly Received Will Likely Send Chills Down Your Spine #2A (fundamentalrefounding.ning.com)
- The Gun Confiscation Notice an NYC Resident Reportedly Received Will Likely Send Chills Down Your Spine (theblaze.com)
State Battles over Gun Control IntensifyPosted: September 14, 2013 Filed under: Self Defense | Tags: Andrew Cuomo, Angela Giron, Colorado, John Morse, Missouri, New York, Phil Bryant, Rick Perry 2 Comments
AWR HAWKINS writes: Battles for and against gun control continue to intensify in various states around the country. Although Colorado took center stage with the recall of state senator John Morse (D-Colorado Springs) and Angela Giron (D-Pueblo) days ago, gun control is or has been the recent focus in Mississippi, Texas, Missouri, New York, and Connecticut.
The good news for gun owners is that the clear majority of the battles are against gun control. Read the rest of this entry »
10 Insanely Overpaid Nonprofit ExecutivesPosted: September 8, 2013 Filed under: Economics | Tags: Andrew Cuomo, Charitable organization, Chronicle of Philanthropy, Fiscal Times, Massachusetts, New Jersey, Nonprofit organization, Salary Leave a comment
Nonprofits take your donations and give them to a good cause, right? To be fair, most do, while paying their employees competitive but modest salaries. But a handful of nonprofits pay their top executives shockingly high salaries that could make their for-profit corporate counterparts jealous.
PHOTO GALLERY: The 10 Highest-Paid Nonprofit Execs Read the rest of this entry »
Obama Administration Praises FrackingPosted: September 3, 2013 Filed under: Economics, Mediasphere | Tags: Andrew Cuomo, Food & Water Watch, Hydraulic fracturing, Moniz, New York, Obama administration, United States Environmental Protection Agency, United States Secretary of Energy Leave a comment
Is Fracking Green?
By Michael Bastasch
Is natural gas the Obama administration’s new tool for tackling global warming?
Trillions of cubic feet of shale gas have been safely extracted using hydraulic fracturing all while reducing U.S. carbon dioxide emissions, said Secretary of Energy Ernest Moniz.
“It’s been a big contributor to our carbon reduction,” Moniz told the New York Daily News editorial board in an interview.
Lecturer-in-ChiefPosted: July 25, 2013 Filed under: Economics, Reading Room | Tags: Andrew Cuomo, Barack Obama, Bill Clinton, George W. Bush, John McCain, Martin Luther King Jr, Obama, United States Leave a comment
President Obama should stick to his real job.
We are now well into the season generally known as the summer doldrums, made more profound and dispiriting this year by the prolonged ineffectiveness of the political system, other than as an agent of sluggishly induced deterioration in public confidence and in the economic strength and international prestige of America. As a constructive thing only, let us focus on two aspects of this — first, the continued addiction of the president to distracting the country with perceptions that are mistaken, probably mendacious, and disserve such interest as there might otherwise be in bootstrapping the United States out of its profound torpor; and second, the failure of anyone I am aware of to recognize the need for a serious reorientation of the economy of the West in a way that only the operation of the free market, though not completely unfettered, can produce.
President Obama won the Democratic nomination in 2008 from Hillary Clinton, despite the fact that Senator Clinton won the primaries, because he rounded up the superdelegates (appointed, rather than elected, delegates), and then the entire country, with the argument that he was the first plausible leader of the African-American community since Martin Luther King Jr. (though General Colin L. Powell could have occupied that role had he wished it), that the time for a non-white president had come, and, more subtly, that conscientious American whites who felt embarrassment, or even guilt or shame, at the past treatment of the African Americans — what Abraham Lincoln called “the bondsman’s 250 years of unrequited toil,” followed by a century of segregation and what Lyndon Johnson called the era of “Nigra, nigra, nigra” — could alleviate their discomfort and expiate their guilt by the simple expedient of electing Barack Obama president. It was an idea that developed an unstoppable momentum before Hillary Clinton or her husband realized what they were facing.
There is no reason to believe that John McCain ever figured it out, as he tried to pick up the torch from a president whose response to an economic crisis to which his own lassitude had importantly contributed (though President Clinton stoked it up with mandated trillions of dollars of non-commercial mortgages) was the stirring tocsin “The sucker could go down.” Senator McCain first declared, in the immortal words of Herbert Hoover, that the economy “is fundamentally sound”; then denounced corporate greed and locked arms with the rest of the political class to pretend that the incompetence and venality of the country’s leaders had nothing to do with it; then demanded that poor old Christopher Cox be handed a pink slip at the SEC to be replaced with, of all unsuitable choices, Andrew Cuomo; and then suspended his campaign (in itself a potentially vote-winning move) and returned to Washington to join in the bipartisan strategy session President Bush convened. He did not say a word at it, and then shared in the failure to pass the emergency stimulus bill (which was a ridiculous bill that looked good only when compared with the Democrats’ subsequent, infamously “shovel-ready” replacement). Given the times, the incumbent, and the Republican campaign, it is a wonder that the sly Obama message, ably and eloquently delivered by him, did not elicit a much greater victory than it did.